Plate of Cake
Whole 9" Cakes
Strawberry Cake
Fresh strawberry layers with light frosting — a crowd pleaser for any celebration.
Jersey City & East Harlem · Open Late
Birthday Cakes
Ready When You Are
Whole cakes, cheesecakes, and celebration desserts available without the boring cake-shop energy. Pickup or delivery in Jersey City and NYC.
★ 4.9 · 1,200+ Reviews
DoorDash · Uber Eats · Seamless
- 🕐 Open Late
- 🚀 Same-Day Pickup
- 🎂 Whole 9" Cakes
- 🧀 Whole Cheesecakes
- 📦 Delivery Available
- ✅ No Advance Order Needed
Available Now
Order Online →
Birthday Cakes & Cheesecakes
Whole cakes from $46.99 and cheesecakes from $55.99. Prices and availability updated daily.
Plate of Cake
Whole 9" Cakes
Triple Chocolate Cake
Three layers of chocolate intensity — for the serious chocolate lovers.
Plate of Cake
Whole 9" Cakes
Black Forest Cake
Chocolate layers, whipped cream, and cherries. The classic crowd-favorite.
Plate of Cake
Whole Cheesecakes
Whole Biscoff Spread Cheesecake
Silky cheesecake on a Biscoff cookie base with caramelized spread layers.
Plate of Cake
Whole Cheesecakes
Whole Pistachio Cheesecake
Rich pistachio cream cheesecake — nutty, elegant, and impossible to forget.
Plate of Cake
Whole Cheesecakes
Whole New York Style Cheesecake
Dense, creamy, and perfectly balanced. The classic. No shortcuts taken.
Menu examples shown — live availability at order.plateofcake.com.
Perfect For
Every Birthday Deserves Something Better
🎉
Birthday Party
Whole cakes that make the table look like you planned this for weeks.
💼
Office Celebration
Bring something people actually get excited about — not sheet cake from the grocery store.
👨👩👧👦
Family Night
Big enough for the whole table. Impressive enough to talk about later.
⏱️
Last-Minute Save
Forgot? We got you. Open late so the party doesn't fall flat.
🎊
Surprise Party
Ready faster than you planned this. No advance order required.
🎈
Kids' Birthdays
Fun flavors with serious quality — no compromises on taste.
Birthday cakes ready when the celebration can't wait.
Skip the basic cake run. Order something people actually talk about — available for same-day pickup in Jersey City and East Harlem.
Order NowReady to Order?
Browse All Whole Cakes & Cheesecakes
9" cakes and whole cheesecakes available for pickup and delivery in Jersey City and East Harlem NYC.
View All Whole Cakes
FAQ
Common Questions About Birthday Cakes
Yes. We offer whole 9-inch layer cakes starting from $46.99 — Strawberry, Black Forest, White Coconut, Carrot, German Chocolate, Triple Chocolate, and more. Available for same-day pickup and delivery in Jersey City and East Harlem, NYC.
Yes. Most of our whole cakes are available for same-day pickup — no advance order required. Order online at order.plateofcake.com and pick up at our Jersey City or East Harlem NYC location.
Our whole cakes are 9-inch layer cakes, typically serving 12–16 people depending on how you slice them. Perfect for birthday parties, office celebrations, and family gatherings.
Yes. We deliver through DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Seamless, plus our own online ordering platform. Delivery availability depends on your distance from our Jersey City or East Harlem locations.
Absolutely. Our whole cheesecakes — New York Style, Biscoff Spread, Pistachio, Strawberry Shine, and more — make an incredible birthday dessert and start at $55.99. Many customers prefer a cheesecake over a traditional layer cake.
Our menu updates daily. If a specific flavor is unavailable, our ordering page shows what's currently in stock. We have a large rotating selection — there's always something great available for your celebration.
Also Explore
More from Plate of Cake