Plate of Cake
Whole Cheesecakes
Whole New York Style Cheesecake
Dense, creamy, and perfectly balanced. The classic. No shortcuts taken.
Jersey City & East Harlem · Open Late
Whole Cheesecakes
For Pickup & Delivery
New York style, Biscoff, pistachio, strawberry, and more — whole cheesecakes ready for your next celebration. No boring bakery energy.
★ 4.9 · 1,200+ Reviews
DoorDash · Uber Eats · Seamless
- 🧀 Whole 9" Cheesecakes
- 🎨 4+ Rotating Flavors
- 🚀 Same-Day Pickup
- 📦 Delivery Available
- 🕐 Open Late
- 👥 Serves 12–16 People
Available Now
Order Online →
Our Whole Cheesecakes
Starting at $55.99. Serves 12–16 people. Availability updated daily.
Plate of Cake
Whole Cheesecakes
Whole Biscoff Spread Cheesecake
Silky cheesecake on a Biscoff cookie base with caramelized spread layers.
Plate of Cake
Whole Cheesecakes
Whole Pistachio Cheesecake
Rich pistachio cream cheesecake — nutty, elegant, and impossible to forget.
Plate of Cake
Whole Cheesecakes
Whole Strawberry Shine Cheesecake
Bright strawberry glaze over a classic New York cheesecake base.
Menu examples shown — live availability at order.plateofcake.com.
Perfect For
Every Moment Deserves a Better Dessert
🍽️
Date Night
Bring home a whole cheesecake. Impress without the restaurant price tag.
💼
Office Treat
A whole cheesecake in the break room hits different than grocery store cookies.
🎂
Birthday Alternative
Skip the traditional layer cake. A whole cheesecake is more memorable anyway.
👨👩👧👦
Family Dessert Night
Big enough for everyone. Impressive enough that nobody asks where you bought it.
💑
Anniversary
The Pistachio or Biscoff cheesecake makes a gift that's actually thoughtful.
⏱️
Last-Minute Gift
We're open late. Order it, pick it up, and nobody knows you forgot.
Whole cheesecakes, ready when you need them.
More variety than a regular cake shop. Pickup in Jersey City and East Harlem. Delivery available through your favorite app.
Order NowReady to Order?
Browse All Whole Cakes & Cheesecakes
9" cakes and whole cheesecakes available for pickup and delivery in Jersey City and East Harlem NYC.
View All Whole Cakes
FAQ
Questions About Whole Cheesecakes
We offer Whole New York Style, Biscoff Spread, Pistachio, and Strawberry Shine cheesecakes, with rotating seasonal flavors. All whole cheesecakes are 9-inch and serve 12–16 people. Prices start at $55.99.
Yes. Our whole cheesecakes are available for same-day pickup at our Jersey City and East Harlem NYC locations. Order online at order.plateofcake.com. No advance order required in most cases.
Our whole 9-inch cheesecakes typically serve 12–16 people depending on slice size. They're ideal for birthday parties, office celebrations, family gatherings, and events where you want to impress.
Our Biscoff Spread and Pistachio cheesecakes are consistently our most ordered flavors. The New York Style is the most classic and never disappoints. All four current flavors have strong followings.
Yes. Whole cheesecakes are available for delivery through DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Seamless, or via our online ordering system. Delivery range depends on your distance from our Jersey City and East Harlem locations.
Our online ordering page shows real-time availability. If one flavor is sold out, our other cheesecake flavors are usually available. We rotate flavors regularly so there's always something great to choose from.
Also Explore
More from Plate of Cake